(CNN)After contending in “The Biggest Loser,” much of the reality-show entrants have actually unwillingly gained back the weight they looked for to lose through severe dieting and workout.

But some participants found on their own the secret to keeping their weight down long after the video cameras switched off, inning accordance with a research study released Monday.
Six years after appearing on the program, a group of 14 candidates had actually deflected a typical 13% of their initial body weight. The scientists divided the group in 2– the “maintainers,” who had actually kept a significant quantity of the weight off, and the “regainers,” who did not– and took a look at exactly what set them apart.


“Did they cut more calories from their diet plan … or did they end up being more physically active?” asked research study author Kevin Hall , a senior detective with the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases.

Hall had actually been “puzzled by how rapidly the participants were slimming down.” He called the program’s doctor and started studying the season 8 candidates.

Early on, Hall observed that weight reduction was much better forecasted by food consumption, not exercise alone. In the long term, the reverse was real.

“You need to be extremely physically active in order to keep the weight off,” Hall stated.

The “maintainers,” who deflected about 25% of their preshow weight typically, increased their exercise by approximately 160% from prior to the competitors. Those who restored the weight increased their activity just 34%. They were 1.1% much heavier usually than their initial weight.

The scientists could not discover any significant distinctions in between the food consumption of both groups; both cut their calories by about the exact same quantity.

“While we understand that the most essential element of assisting one drop weight is the dietary consumption, that is basically reversed when it pertains to weight reduction upkeep,” stated Dr. Jennifer Kraschnewski , associate teacher of medication and public health sciences at the Penn State College of Medicine. She was not associated with the research study.



Hall’s findings echo previous research studies that promote more workout for long-lasting weight-loss upkeep. Professionals warn that does not imply individuals can overlook their diet plans in the long run, either.

To keep the weight-loss, Hall’s group approximated that entrants would have to take part in 80 minutes of moderate activity or 35 minutes of energetic activity every day beyond exactly what they were doing at standard.

This is far beyond the leading standards for exercise from groups like the American Heart Association and the United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention , which “are far too low for keeping weight reduction,” Hall stated.

The scientists didn’t observe the entrants exercising straight. They utilized tools like traceable water particles to determine just how much energy was used up– the “gold requirement” measurements in this kind of research study, Kraschnewski stated. Numerous bigger research studies have actually rather asked individuals to self-report what does it cost? they worked out, which can be filled with mistakes.

This technique, nevertheless, was unable to inform just how much of the exercise was because of typical day-to-day activities– like cleaning up your house or strolling the pet dog– versus following an exercise strategy, Hall stated.

Part of the factor the participants’ weight rebounded was since of “metabolic slowing down,” Hall stated. As entrants slimmed down throughout the competitors, their bodies burned less calories than anticipated.



“This can make it harder to drop weight and is another difficulty to get rid of,” Kraschnewski stated. After going on an extremely low-calorie diet plan, “the body’s systems start to maintain body mass at all expenses.”

Six years later on, nevertheless, the candidates’ resting metabolic process still had not sped back up, Hall displayed in a research study in 2015.

This is a plain distinction from individuals who have actually had stomach coronary bypass for weight reduction, whose metabolic process might speed back up in a year’s time, Kraschnewski stated. Scientists are aiming to find out why this is– and it might have something to do with the detailed connections in between the gut, brain and hormonal agents that manage appetite, Kraschnewski included.

For Hall, metabolic modifications are simply one part of the puzzle. Genetics might likewise contribute, along with social elements that can make it hard for some individuals to integrate a lot workout in their every day lives.

“To do that needs a substantial financial investment of time and energy,” he stated. “The bar is set really high for those folks to be able to preserve the weight reduction without surgical treatment or drugs.”

See the current news and share your remarks with CNN Health on Facebook and Twitter .

Hall included that it’s not always those who were most physically active throughout the competitors who kept it up 6 years later on.
“You cannot actually replicate the expectation that those people need to have had on the program to reduce weight– the pressure,” Kraschnewski stated.
“The take-home point here is that weight problems truly is an illness,” she stated. “It’s not something that you can deal with when and will treat it. It’s something that needs to be constantly resolved in one’s life.”

Read more: https://www.cnn.com/2017/11/03/health/biggest-loser-diet-exercise-study/index.html