Fillet or shoulder? Lemon juice or vinegar for the marinade? Heres the definitive way to make souvlaki be sure to finish with a sprinkling of paprika

Souvlakis name derives from the medieval Greek for skewer, but grilling meat on sticks was a practice taken from the Muslim cooks of the near east. As the Oxford Companion to Food notes, these days theyre often made of un-Islamic pork. Often, but not always, you will find chicken and lamb versions (indeed, in Australia, where post-pub souvas are an institution, lamb is apparently the default).

But the consensus on Twitter seems to be that pork is the classic iteration in souvlakis homeland, albeit consumed in very different ways depending on where you are wrapped in bread or on a plate; on its own or with chips, salad, onions, pickles, herbs, and a whole array of sauces; or simply eaten straight from a pointy piece of wood by the side of the road. But whats the best way to make it at home?

The meat

The two most common cuts used in the souvlaki recipes I try are tenderloin (generally called fillet in this country), or neck and shoulder. The latter, Belinda Harley notes in her book Roast Lamb in the Olive Groves, should have a little fat left on so that it doesnt dry out. As a devotee of the fat-means-flavour school of thought, I expect that the well-marbled shoulder I try will be far superior to the lean fillet, and that the pork belly used by Tonia Buxton in the Real Greek Cookbook will be better still. But we decide that, cooked quickly on a high heat, the tenderness of the fillet wins us over. That said, theres little to beat the taste of good-quality chargrilled pork fat, so Ive decided to use a combination of shoulder and fillet; belly is a little too rich, even for us.

Harley cuts the meat into very small pieces for her mini kebabs, but if you keep them a little larger, theyll stay juicier during cooking.

The marinade

The simplest marinades come from Harley and Tessa Kiros Falling Cloudberries: lemon juice, oregano, and olive oil, with bay leaves in Harleys too. Georgina Haydens Taverna, which celebrates the food of her Greek Cypriot family, uses garlic, fresh rosemary and thyme, with red-wine vinegar instead of the lemon juice. Greek celebrity chef Akis Petretzikis uses white wine vinegar and garlic along with olive oil and oregano. (He also sticks in a chicken stock cube, giving the meat a deliciously savoury quality though Id prefer to let salt do the seasoning, and the pork speak for itself.

Buxtons recipe, as used at the Real Greek chain, is quite a different beast: the sticky, aromatic marinade of orange juice, honey, mustard, paprika, cinnamon and fennel seeds reminds us (not unhappily) of Chinese roast pork rather than souvlaki. This comparison is encouraged by the fact its cooked in the oven, rather than on a grill, and so lacks the char that, my testers say, is vital for transportation-back-to-Greece purposes.

Memories of Greek holidays also prompt my decision to go for dried oregano, rather than Haydens fresh herbs, delicious though they are. My guinea pigs, one of whom follows a largely vegetarian diet, rate them as more interesting, but say the oregano is the thing that sings to them of Greece. We all love the garlic though, so Im going to keep that, and use lemon juice rather than vinegar as you can squeeze the other half over the salad.

Some recipes, including Kiros, brush the marinade on the meat just before cooking, but youll get more flavour if you leave them to mingle for a little longer I wouldnt recommend more than three or four hours though, lest the acid in the lemon juice begins to toughen the meat.

The accompaniments

Hayden gives two serving suggestions for her souvlaki: The more traditional Greek way, with round fluffy pitta breads, chips and mustard sauce and the Cypriot way: in oval pitta breads, with shredded cabbage and griddled olives.

Intrigued by the mayonnaise-based mustard sauce, and tempted by the chips, I opt for the former, but her creamy tzatziki is so very good that most testers opt for that instead. Id have to alternate, the lapsing vegetarian says through a mouthful of meat, I cant taste them both together.

Petretzikis is the only one to add vegetables to the skewers themselves, in the form of red onions and peppers. They are a good combination with the charred pork like a home barbecue from the 80s! Martha says joyfully but are very much an optional extra. Its easier, I think, to serve the skewers with a tomato salad, perhaps with some thinly sliced red onion and chopped parsley, as most recipes recommend. (Like Kiros, I prefer to soak my onions for a milder flavour, but if youre less of a wimp, feel free to ignore this step.)

Chips are, of course, always a possibility, but bread is a must. Oval Arabic pitta are the most widely available here, but if youre lucky enough to have access to a shop selling fluffier, round flatbreads (I got mine from a Turkish greengrocers), theyre much easier to roll up around the meat, and better at soaking up the juices too. Or, if youre more of a sourdough sort, Harley suggests using slices of country bread as a plate.

Ill leave the last word on souvlaki to Hayden, a woman practically weaned on them: Be sure to finish with a sprinkle of paprika.

Prep 30 min
Soak 20 min
Cook 15 min
Makes 4

For the skewers
600g pork tenderloin
200g pork shoulder
2 garlic cloves, peeled and crushed
100ml olive oil
Juice of lemon
1 tbsp dried oregano
tsp fine salt

To serve
red onion, peeled
4 large tomatoes
Juice of lemon
1 small bunch flat-leaf parsley, roughly chopped
4 flatbreads
200g tzatziki
1 pinch paprika

Cut the tenderloin and shoulder into cubes of roughly 2x3cm. Whisk together the crushed garlic, oil, lemon juice, oregano and salt in a container large enough to hold all the meat, then add the cubes and turn until well coated.

Cover and leave to sit in a cool place for between one and four hours.

Soak four wooden skewers in water, if using.

About half an hour before you want to eat, slice the onion very thinly. For a milder flavour, put in a bowl of cold water and leave to soak for 20 minutes.

Meanwhile, slice the tomatoes and arrange on a plate. Season and sprinkle with lemon juice, then scatter with the drained onion and the parsley.

Prepare a barbecue, or heat a griddle pan until smoking hot. Thread the meat on to the skewers, pushing it together so you cant see any skewer between the pieces. Griddle on all sides until well browned and cooked through. Meanwhile, warm the flatbreads in another hot pan or a low oven.

Sprinkle the skewers with paprika and serve with salad, tzatziki and bread.

• Does souvlaki mean pork, chicken or lamb to you or something even more exotic? How do you like to eat them, and where does the best version youve ever had?

^{This article contains affiliate links, which means we may earn a small commission if a reader clicks through and makes a purchase. All our journalism is independent and is in no way influenced by any advertiser or commercial initiative. By clicking on an affiliate link, you accept that third-party cookies will be set.} More information.

Read more: https://www.theguardian.com/food/2019/sep/04/how-to-cook-the-perfect-souvlaki-greek-kebab